AutoDefects
English

MPVs

Renault Scénic / Grand Scénic reliability

In 61,335 UK MOT tests, 32.3% of Renault Scénic / Grand Scénic cars failed for a mechanical or structural defect. The median MPV of the same age and mileage: 26.6%.

57of 100Below average22% more mechanical failures than the class
Best years
—
Years with most failures
2014, 2015, 2019
Weak spot at high mileage
Steering, Suspension and wheels
Official recalls
11 recalls, 5 serious
Mechanical failure rate
32.3%
Class median, same age and mileage
26.6%
MOT tests
61,335
US owner complaints
0

MOT results by test year

The whole fleet of this model at each year’s MOT, against its class at the same age and mileage. Shows whether the model keeps its standing as it ages.

MOT yearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny fail
202461,33532.3%26.6%45.0%
202371,48631.8%26.8%44.3%

Failure rate by year of first registration

Mechanical failure rate at the 2024 MOT, by the year the car was first registered, against the median of its class at the same age and mileage.

This modelClass median
0%15%30%2004: 37.7%2004 Class median: 34.5%042005: 41.5%2005 Class median: 34.3%052006: 38.5%2006 Class median: 37.6%062007: 38.8%2007 Class median: 36.1%072008: 38.4%2008 Class median: 35.8%082009: 36.1%2009 Class median: 36.0%092010: 37.2%2010 Class median: 31.7%102011: 36.1%2011 Class median: 27.7%112012: 34.5%2012 Class median: 24.6%122013: 34.6%2013 Class median: 22.3%132014: 31.6%2014 Class median: 19.6%142015: 23.4%2015 Class median: 14.5%152016: 18.3%2016 Class median: 12.3%162017: 15.1%2017 Class median: 11.2%172018: 10.0%2018 Class median: 9.1%182019: 11.6%2019 Class median: 6.4%192020: 6.9%2020 Class median: 5.7%20
YearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny failRecalls
20202766.9%5.7%16.3%0
20191,19511.6%6.4%24.9%2
20181,28110.0%9.1%24.2%3
20172,64815.1%11.2%28.7%0
20162,73918.3%12.3%32.5%4
20154,47023.4%14.5%35.6%1
20144,04331.6%19.6%43.1%1
20133,43634.6%22.3%45.5%0
20124,17334.5%24.6%46.0%0
20117,86036.1%27.7%48.5%0
201010,28937.2%31.7%49.5%0
20093,11336.1%36.0%49.6%0
20083,61438.4%35.8%52.3%0
20074,02838.8%36.1%52.1%0
20062,70838.5%37.6%51.1%0
20051,34241.5%34.3%52.5%0
200469037.7%34.5%52.5%0
Older years (5)
YearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny failRecalls
20031,15432.4%37.6%45.7%0
20021,11428.7%34.6%45.1%0
200173631.3%33.1%46.7%0
200035835.8%36.6%44.7%0
19995328.3%—%35.9%0

What fails, by mileage

Share of MOT tests that failed on each system. Wear items (bulbs, tyres, wipers, plates) are excluded from the reliability score.

System0-50k km50-100k km100-150k km150k+ km
Mechanical fail11.3% (9.0)21.5% (15.4)32.9% (25.0)39.1% (34.8)
Tests2,61412,49019,97826,253
Suspension and wheels5.6% (1.5)11.1% (4.4)18.4% (10.3)23.4% (17.1)
Brakes3.1% (2.1)7.3% (5.3)10.9% (8.3)13.8% (12.7)
Engine, exhaust and emissions1.3% (0.9)2.2% (1.4)3.3% (2.9)5.0% (5.6)
Steering1.0% (0.2)3.8% (0.6)8.4% (2.0)11.2% (4.5)
Body, chassis and corrosion2.3% (0.4)3.9% (1.6)5.9% (3.8)7.4% (7.0)
Seat belts and airbags0.6% (0.3)0.7% (0.6)1.2% (0.9)1.8% (1.7)
Lights and electrics (wear)8.0% (3.3)14.8% (7.9)22.2% (14.3)27.6% (22.0)
Tyres (wear)5.4% (4.4)6.0% (6.0)7.5% (8.2)8.5% (10.0)
Wipers and windscreen (wear)4.1% (3.4)4.8% (3.9)5.9% (4.7)7.3% (6.0)
Other and plates (wear)0.2% (0.1)0.3% (0.2)0.3% (0.3)0.4% (0.5)

(…) = Class median, same age and mileage

Pre-purchase checklist for the mechanic

Built from the systems where this model fails more often than its class at 100,000 km and above, and from open recalls.

  1. Steering: check for play in the rack, track rod ends and column, power-steering leaks and noise on full lock.
  2. Suspension and wheels: check arms, bushes, ball joints, springs and shock absorbers for play, cracks and leaks; look for uneven tyre wear.
  3. Recalls: 5 serious recalls name this model — ask for proof the work was done
    • A12/01170/20 · 2018, 2019 · The fuel line may be damaged.As a result, fuel may leak onto the road, posing a risk to the following traffic. Furthermore, fuel leakage on…
    • A12/1791/19 · 2018, 2019 · The NOx sensors may not be properly tightened. This may result in an increased risk of fire.
    • A12/0556/19 · 2018 · Capacitors may crack under mechanical stress of the electronic board and overheat. This could lead to a malfunction of the engine cooling…
    • A12/0765/17 · 2016 · null The mixture ratio of the ignition chemicals in the inflators for the window airbags is not correct. This could prevent the window…
    • A12/0006/16 · 2014, 2015 · null The drive rotor of the vacuum pump could break, leading to the immediate stop of the vacuum pump and consequent loss of braking…

    Check a specific car by its VIN on the official sites: NHTSA (US) · DVSA (UK)

Official recalls

Recalls published by the US NHTSA and the EU Safety Gate that name this model. Check by VIN whether a specific car is affected.

  • EU Safety Gate2024, 2025

    The position sensor of the parking brake actuator is at the wrong angle, causing the stopping pin to be incorrectly placed in the ‘P lock’ position and resulting in the parking brake not properly engaging when the P…

    Full text

    The position sensor of the parking brake actuator is at the wrong angle, causing the stopping pin to be incorrectly placed in the ‘P lock’ position and resulting in the parking brake not properly engaging when the P button is pressed on the transmission selector, when the engine is switched off, when the driver’s safety-belt is released or when the driver door is opened. This increases the risk of accidents and injuries, although the Assisted Parking Brake (APB) remains functional and allows the vehicle to be immobilised.

    OR/00145/25 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2024, 2025

    The position sensor of the parking brake actuator is at the wrong angle, causing the stopping pin to be incorrectly placed in the ‘P lock’ position and resulting in the parking brake not properly engaging when the P…

    Full text

    The position sensor of the parking brake actuator is at the wrong angle, causing the stopping pin to be incorrectly placed in the ‘P lock’ position and resulting in the parking brake not properly engaging when the P button is pressed on the transmission selector, when the engine is switched off, when the driver’s safety-belt is released or when the driver door is opened. This increases the risk of accidents and injuries, although the Assisted Parking Brake (APB) remains functional and allows the vehicle to be immobilised.

    SR/03262/25 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2018, 2019

    The fuel line may be damaged.As a result, fuel may leak onto the road, posing a risk to the following traffic. Furthermore, fuel leakage on hot parts of the exhaust system will increase the risk of the vehicle catching…

    A12/01170/20 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2018, 2019

    The NOx sensors may not be properly tightened. This may result in an increased risk of fire.

    A12/1791/19 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2018

    Capacitors may crack under mechanical stress of the electronic board and overheat. This could lead to a malfunction of the engine cooling fan assembly, increasing the risk of a fire.

    A12/0556/19 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2016

    The LED module for monitoring and managing the actuation of the rear lights of the trailer could be damaged. Total failure of the rear lights of the trailer could occur.

    A12/0622/18 ↗
Show 5 more recalls
  • EU Safety GateSerious2016

    null The mixture ratio of the ignition chemicals in the inflators for the window airbags is not correct. This could prevent the window airbags from inflating in the event of an accident.

    A12/0765/17 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2016

    null Part of the sound insulation can detach which can cause the automatic parking brake to be released unintentionally.

    A12/0677/17 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2016

    null The rear screws on the front seat runners were not tightened. In the event of an accident or sudden braking, the front seats may tip forwards owing to the poor attachment or breakage of the seat runner's fittings.

    A12/1343/16 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2014, 2015

    null The drive rotor of the vacuum pump could break, leading to the immediate stop of the vacuum pump and consequent loss of braking assistance and loss of engine power.

    A12/0006/16 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate

    null There is a risk that the brake pedal becomes stiff due to a lack of braking assistance when the vehicle repeatedly slows down or stops on a slope with the engine at idle speed.

    A12/1460/12 ↗