Methodology
What we count
Every normal MOT test of a car (class 4) in the UK DVSA anonymised MOT dataset for 2024. Retests, appeals, aborted and refused tests are left out, and duplicate rows in the official files are counted once.
Mechanical failures
A test counts as a mechanical failure when it failed (or passed only after a repair at the test station) on suspension, wheels, brakes, steering, engine, exhaust, emissions, body, chassis, corrosion, seat belts or airbags. Failures only on bulbs, tyres, wipers or number plates are wear items: they are shown, but they do not affect the score.
Age and mileage
Older and higher-mileage cars fail more often. So each model is compared with the median model of its class in the same year of first registration and the same mileage band (0–50k, 50–100k, 100–150k, 150k+ km). The class median is the expected rate; the ratio between the model and this expectation is what we score.
Reliability score (0–100)
Start at 72. Up to ±26 points from the mechanical failure ratio (65%), up to ±5 from the share of US owner complaints that involve a crash, fire, injury or death compared with the class (25%), and up to ±4 from the failure ratio at 150,000 km and above (10%). The result is limited to 20–98. 80 and above is high, 65–79 average, below 65 below average. Models with fewer than 100 US complaints get a neutral safety input.
Best and worst years
Years with at least 300 tests, from the last 20 years. Best years fail at least 5% less than the class; years with most failures fail at least 10% more.
Checklist
Up to three mechanical systems that fail more than 1.5 percentage points above the class at 100,000 km and above, plus a recall check when a serious recall names the model.
When a page is indexed
A model page is indexed when it has at least 500 MOT tests or 25 US complaints and recalls together; a year page with at least 150 tests or 3 recalls. Thinner pages stay available but are not indexed.
Limits
MOT tests are British cars at British inspections; problems that do not fail an MOT (gearboxes, infotainment) are not counted. Model years follow the date of first registration. Recalls are matched to models by name; check a specific car by VIN. Nothing on this site is written or scored by AI.