AutoDefects
English

Most reliable premium compact

Every model in the class, ranked by the reliability score. Mechanical failure rate is compared with the class at the same age and mileage.

#ModelReliability scoreMechanical failClass medianBest yearsTests
1Lexus IS9810.4%18.3%2017, 2018, 202032,119
2Lexus CT985.8%11.2%2014, 2018, 201931,068
3BMW 4 Series875.7%7.9%2015, 2016, 2021106,679
4Audi A58511.7%12.9%2007, 2009, 2012127,889
5BMW 3 Series7914.1%16.4%2014, 2015, 2016496,041
6MINI Clubman796.4%7.3%2013, 2015, 201827,473
7BMW 1 Series7712.1%13.0%2014, 2015, 2022399,143
8Alfa Romeo Giulia764.7%4.9%2017, 20186,746
9Audi A47517.7%17.1%2009, 2012, 2022257,281
10Audi A3 / S37215.2%14.3%2016, 2017, 2021428,917
11BMW 2 Series725.9%6.0%2019, 2020125,841
12Volvo S606817.9%17.6%2004, 2010, 202120,225
13Jaguar XE628.4%7.3%—43,952
14Mercedes-Benz C-Class6117.4%14.4%2019374,109
15Mercedes-Benz A-Class4711.5%8.6%—353,033
16Mercedes-Benz B-Class4617.0%12.6%2018, 2020, 202172,426
17Mercedes-Benz CLA459.0%6.7%202263,853
18Volvo V404217.3%10.4%—98,689