AutoDefects
English

BMW 1 Series vs Mercedes-Benz A-Class

Side by side, from the same official data and the same method.

MeasureBMW 1 SeriesMercedes-Benz A-Class
Reliability score77 of 100 · Average47 of 100 · Below average
Mechanical failure rate12.1%11.5%
Class median, same age and mileage13.0%8.6%
Failed MOT (any reason)23.9%21.2%
MOT tests399,143353,033
Best years2014, 2015, 2022—
Years with most failures—2011, 2015, 2019
Recalls867
US owner complaints082
Mechanical fail 0-50k km1.8%3.0%
Mechanical fail 50-100k km5.7%8.4%
Mechanical fail 100-150k km11.7%16.0%
Mechanical fail 150k+ km21.6%25.2%

BMW 1 Series

This modelClass median
0%11%22%2004: 28.1%2004 Class median: 30.5%042005: 27.8%2005 Class median: 28.8%2006: 26.3%2006 Class median: 28.1%062007: 23.9%2007 Class median: 26.4%2008: 24.1%2008 Class median: 25.9%082009: 23.0%2009 Class median: 25.1%2010: 21.2%2010 Class median: 21.5%102011: 19.5%2011 Class median: 18.3%2012: 18.1%2012 Class median: 18.3%122013: 14.1%2013 Class median: 14.6%2014: 10.6%2014 Class median: 13.5%142015: 8.5%2015 Class median: 10.7%2016: 7.9%2016 Class median: 8.8%162017: 5.9%2017 Class median: 6.8%2018: 5.2%2018 Class median: 5.4%182019: 4.1%2019 Class median: 4.3%2020: 2.6%2020 Class median: 2.9%202021: 1.9%2021 Class median: 2.1%2022: 0.8%2022 Class median: 0.9%22

Mercedes-Benz A-Class

This modelClass median
0%14%27%1999: 37.3%1999 Class median: 22.5%992000: 34.5%2000 Class median: 23.8%2001: 31.1%2001 Class median: 28.0%012002: 31.0%2002 Class median: 24.5%2003: 29.9%2003 Class median: 25.9%032004: 29.0%2004 Class median: 26.0%2005: 28.7%2005 Class median: 24.8%052006: 31.1%2006 Class median: 23.9%2007: 28.1%2007 Class median: 23.3%072008: 29.2%2008 Class median: 22.8%2009: 25.8%2009 Class median: 21.0%092010: 22.9%2010 Class median: 17.5%2011: 20.7%2011 Class median: 14.3%112012: 20.1%2012 Class median: 14.4%2013: 20.3%2013 Class median: 14.5%132014: 18.8%2014 Class median: 13.5%2015: 14.8%2015 Class median: 10.6%152016: 11.7%2016 Class median: 8.6%2017: 8.5%2017 Class median: 6.8%172018: 7.2%2018 Class median: 5.3%2019: 6.9%2019 Class median: 4.3%192020: 4.0%2020 Class median: 3.0%2021: 2.2%2021 Class median: 2.2%212022: 1.4%2022 Class median: 1.2%