AutoDefects
English

City cars

smart fortwo / forfour reliability

In 75,615 UK MOT tests, 16.4% of smart fortwo / forfour cars failed for a mechanical or structural defect. The median city car of the same age and mileage: 18.1%.

75of 100Average9% fewer mechanical failures than the class
Best years
2004, 2011, 2014
Years with most failures
2015, 2016, 2019
Weak spot at high mileage
Nothing stands out against the class
Official recalls
17 recalls, 6 serious
Mechanical failure rate
16.4%
Class median, same age and mileage
18.1%
MOT tests
75,615
US owner complaints
240

MOT results by test year

The whole fleet of this model at each year’s MOT, against its class at the same age and mileage. Shows whether the model keeps its standing as it ages.

MOT yearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny fail
202475,61516.4%18.1%28.2%
202377,91915.2%16.6%27.0%

Failure rate by year of first registration

Mechanical failure rate at the 2024 MOT, by the year the car was first registered, against the median of its class at the same age and mileage.

This modelClass median
0%14%28%2004: 27.8%2004 Class median: 38.6%042005: 29.2%2005 Class median: 35.7%052006: 27.3%2006 Class median: 35.0%062007: 27.1%2007 Class median: 31.3%072008: 25.9%2008 Class median: 33.6%082009: 25.3%2009 Class median: 30.3%092010: 23.4%2010 Class median: 28.1%102011: 19.6%2011 Class median: 25.9%112012: 17.5%2012 Class median: 19.5%122013: 16.6%2013 Class median: 18.3%132014: 11.0%2014 Class median: 15.6%142015: 17.3%2015 Class median: 13.2%152016: 14.2%2016 Class median: 12.4%162017: 9.1%2017 Class median: 8.6%172018: 6.2%2018 Class median: 5.8%182019: 4.6%2019 Class median: 4.0%19
YearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny failRecalls
20193,8324.6%4.0%15.6%2
20187,2116.2%5.8%17.3%0
20179,5589.1%8.6%21.3%2
201611,04714.2%12.4%24.9%1
20157,69417.3%13.2%29.5%4
20143,75311.0%15.6%22.8%3
20133,38616.6%18.3%28.7%0
20122,62317.5%19.5%28.3%1
20113,77619.6%25.9%31.9%0
20105,28123.4%28.1%34.7%0
20095,59225.3%30.3%36.9%1
20084,59825.9%33.6%37.7%1
20072,25327.1%31.3%39.1%0
20061,92627.3%35.0%41.8%0
20051,77529.2%35.7%44.1%0
200498527.8%38.6%42.8%0
Older years (2)
YearTestsMechanical failClass medianAny failRecalls
200315425.3%39.6%41.6%0
20028330.1%36.6%39.8%0

What fails, by mileage

Share of MOT tests that failed on each system. Wear items (bulbs, tyres, wipers, plates) are excluded from the reliability score.

System0-50k km50-100k km100-150k km150k+ km
Mechanical fail6.4% (6.2)16.2% (16.8)24.7% (28.5)29.1% (37.1)
Tests20,60532,53116,2256,254
Suspension and wheels2.1% (1.9)7.1% (7.1)12.0% (12.6)15.2% (16.3)
Brakes2.8% (2.6)6.0% (6.2)9.3% (11.2)11.3% (15.8)
Engine, exhaust and emissions1.6% (0.8)4.6% (2.0)7.5% (4.3)9.3% (7.8)
Steering0.1% (0.1)0.3% (0.5)1.1% (1.0)2.8% (1.6)
Body, chassis and corrosion0.7% (0.7)2.1% (2.2)4.0% (4.7)6.4% (7.4)
Seat belts and airbags0.1% (0.2)0.3% (0.4)0.6% (1.1)1.2% (1.8)
Lights and electrics (wear)3.7% (3.2)9.5% (8.3)17.3% (16.4)23.5% (22.1)
Tyres (wear)4.2% (3.4)6.8% (6.0)7.8% (7.6)7.5% (8.9)
Wipers and windscreen (wear)4.3% (3.9)5.6% (4.9)6.4% (6.1)7.5% (7.5)
Other and plates (wear)0.2% (0.1)0.3% (0.2)0.6% (0.3)0.8% (0.5)

(…) = Class median, same age and mileage

Pre-purchase checklist for the mechanic

Built from the systems where this model fails more often than its class at 100,000 km and above, and from open recalls.

  1. Recalls: 5 serious recalls name this model — ask for proof the work was done
    • A12/01245/21 · 2020 · The windscreen may be incorrectly bonded and could become detached from the body of the car in the event of a crash. The passenger airbag…
    • A12/00748/20 · 2019 · The internal welds in the main cell diverters (connection between the individual cells and cell modules) of the high-voltage battery may…
    • 20V107000 · 2019 · Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling one 2019 Smart Fortwo Electric Drive vehicle. A welded joint within the high-voltage battery…
    • 18V273000 · 2008, 2009 · Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling certain 2008-2009 smart fortwo cabrio and fortwo coupe vehicles. The rear insulation mat in…
    • A12/0808/15 · 2015 · null In the event of a crash with the affected vehicles in which the driver's knee airbag is deployed, it cannot be ruled out that parts of…

    Check a specific car by its VIN on the official sites: NHTSA (US) · DVSA (UK)

Official recalls

Recalls published by the US NHTSA and the EU Safety Gate that name this model. Check by VIN whether a specific car is affected.

  • EU Safety Gate2022–2025

    The wheel bolts were not tightened in accordance with the torque specifications. The bolts and the wheel assembly could detach while the vehicle is in motion, increasing the risk of accidents.

    SR/01579/26 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2022

    The screw between the rear axle and the body can come loose, causingdisconnection or even complete detachment of the centre bearing of the rear axle from the body. In this case, the wheel guidance can be lost, creating…

    Full text

    The screw between the rear axle and the body can come loose, causingdisconnection or even complete detachment of the centre bearing of the rear axle from the body. In this case, the wheel guidance can be lost, creating a risk of an accident.

    A12/00175/23 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2020

    The windscreen may be incorrectly bonded and could become detached from the body of the car in the event of a crash. The passenger airbag being deployed in this case, could not be supported by the windscreen as…

    Full text

    The windscreen may be incorrectly bonded and could become detached from the body of the car in the event of a crash. The passenger airbag being deployed in this case, could not be supported by the windscreen as intended. As a result, the restraining effect of the passenger airbag could be impaired, increasing the risk of injury.

    A12/01245/21 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2020

    The adhesive bond between the roof section and the roof frame may become weak over time.As a result, the roof could become completely detached from the vehicle, increasing the risk of accident and injury for other road…

    Full text

    The adhesive bond between the roof section and the roof frame may become weak over time.As a result, the roof could become completely detached from the vehicle, increasing the risk of accident and injury for other road users.

    A12/01071/21 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2019

    The internal welds in the main cell diverters (connection between the individual cells and cell modules) of the high-voltage battery may not meet the specifications and could break, interrupting the electrical contact…

    Full text

    The internal welds in the main cell diverters (connection between the individual cells and cell modules) of the high-voltage battery may not meet the specifications and could break, interrupting the electrical contact within the battery.This would result in the immediate failure of the whole battery, increasing the risk of an accident.Furthermore, electric arching may occur in the damaged battery, increasing the risk of fire.

    A12/00748/20 ↗
  • NHTSA (US)Serious2019

    Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling one 2019 Smart Fortwo Electric Drive vehicle. A welded joint within the high-voltage battery main cell conductors may detach and interrupt electrical contact, resulting in…

    Full text

    Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling one 2019 Smart Fortwo Electric Drive vehicle. A welded joint within the high-voltage battery main cell conductors may detach and interrupt electrical contact, resulting in sudden battery failure. The detached weld may also cause an electrical arc which can ignite inside the battery cells.

    20V107000 ↗
Show 11 more recalls
  • NHTSA (US)Serious2008, 2009

    Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling certain 2008-2009 smart fortwo cabrio and fortwo coupe vehicles. The rear insulation mat in the engine compartment may deform, deteriorate, and loosen over time, allowing the…

    Full text

    Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling certain 2008-2009 smart fortwo cabrio and fortwo coupe vehicles. The rear insulation mat in the engine compartment may deform, deteriorate, and loosen over time, allowing the mat to contact hot exhaust system components.

    18V273000 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2017

    null The strength of the left front steering knuckle may be insufficient. As a result, the steering knuckle could break, affecting the control of the vehicle.

    A12/1405/17 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2014, 2015

    null As a result of the weakening of the braking rope wrench adjustment knob, the hand brake lever travel could be prolonged gradually. Thus, the parking brake may not exert the necessary force in all situations.

    A12/1330/17 ↗
  • NHTSA (US)2016

    In these vehicles, the lock nut that secures the parking brake cable to the parking brake lever may loosen over time, resulting in increased parking brake lever travel before the parking brake engages.

    Full text

    Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC (MBUSA) is recalling certain 2016 smart fortwo vehicles. In these vehicles, the lock nut that secures the parking brake cable to the parking brake lever may loosen over time, resulting in increased parking brake lever travel before the parking brake engages.

    17V448000 ↗
  • NHTSA (US)2017

    Mercedes-Benz USA LLC. (MBUSA) is recalling certain 2017 smart fortwo and smart fortwo Cabriolet vehicles. Casting imperfections may result in the failure of the left front axle steering knuckle.

    17V447000 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2014, 2015

    null The anchorage for the rear seat backrest may not be sufficiently resistant. In the event of a head-on crash, heavy objects in the boot may put stress on the rear seat backrest, the anchorage could detach from the…

    Full text

    null The anchorage for the rear seat backrest may not be sufficiently resistant. In the event of a head-on crash, heavy objects in the boot may put stress on the rear seat backrest, the anchorage could detach from the body and the backrest could fold forward. This may cause objects in the boot to hit the passengers or passengers could be injured by the folding backrest seat.

    A12/0766/16 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2014, 2015

    null At high vehicle speed, combined with strong wind, the plastic front service hatch (located between the windscreen and headlights) can detach from the vehicle and fall into the traffic area.

    A12/0730/16 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious2015

    null In the event of a crash with the affected vehicles in which the driver's knee airbag is deployed, it cannot be ruled out that parts of the airbag might come loose, increasing the risk of injury for the driver.

    A12/0808/15 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate

    null The steering mechanism screws used for some vehicles may break, especially if subject to repeated vibrations. This may cause loss of control of the vehicle.

    A12/0712/15 ↗
  • EU Safety Gate2012

    null On the front-right brake caliper mounting, the tightening torque of the fastening bolts is inadequate. This can result in the brake caliper and the wheel rim coming into contact with each other. This can lead to…

    Full text

    null On the front-right brake caliper mounting, the tightening torque of the fastening bolts is inadequate. This can result in the brake caliper and the wheel rim coming into contact with each other. This can lead to loss of control of the vehicle, causing a risk of an accident.

    A12/0396/14 ↗
  • EU Safety GateSerious

    The car poses a risk of injury because due to an assembly fault, the seatbelt receivers and seats in some vehicles may not have been screwed in correctly, and the belt receivers and seats may not therefore withstand the…

    Full text

    The car poses a risk of injury because due to an assembly fault, the seatbelt receivers and seats in some vehicles may not have been screwed in correctly, and the belt receivers and seats may not therefore withstand the resulting stresses.

    0552/06 ↗

US owner complaints (NHTSA)

240 complaints filed by US owners with NHTSA. Counts follow sales, so compare shares, not totals.

US owner complaints
240
Crashes
11
Fires
46
Injuries
15

Systems complained about most

  • Engine, exhaust and emissions136
  • Seat belts and airbags71
  • Body, chassis and corrosion19
  • Brakes12
  • Suspension and wheels9

What owners report

Verbatim from US owner complaints to NHTSA (in English). Owner reports are not verified.

  • 2015Engine, exhaust and emissionsSeriousNHTSA #11650674
    Sunday 3/23 I was driving west on 225 heading towards work, all of a sudden the check engine light comes on and all kinds of other lights on the dash came on. I got pulled over and looked in the rear view mirror I seen flames. Quickly grabbed my stuff and got out of the car. The investigation at the time stated most of the heat was coming from the engine
  • 2016SteeringSeriousNHTSA #11457487
    Since purchasing the car the power steering has been bad. The dealership where I purchased the car and Mercedes refused to fix the issue. There is electrical issues and the gas tank gauge and gas tank have been replaced 3 times. Please do not purchase a Smart Car thecmakers do not stand behind their product. I took it to Mercedes Hampton VA Auto Mall and they are so rude. I have almost died 4 times due to bot bring…
  • 2016Seat belts and airbagsSeriousNHTSA #11457491
    Since I purchased the car from Hampton Auto Mall 757 865 8000 there has been an issue with the steering, brakes, gas system, fuel gauge etc.. The dealership or Mercedes refuses to fix the problem since I purchased it in 2016. I have almost died due to steering problems and gas tank. Please get a mechanic to check the steering and for small tears in your gas tank on Smarts. The dealership I bought my car from refuses…
  • 2016Body, chassis and corrosionSeriousNHTSA #11432522
    The roof detached on the highway. It was just replaced by Mercedes Benz in Manhattan and a couple of weeks later when it went on a highway, the roof flew up and I had to hold on to it for dear life while I was searching for a shoulder since they don’t have them everywhere on the East Coast. I didn’t want anyone behind me to be killed. I didn’t want myself to be killed either. It’s very hard to drive with wind and a…
  • 2016BrakesSeriousNHTSA #11383048
    TL* THE CONTACT OWNED A 2016 SMART FORTWO. THE CONTACT STATED THAT WHILE DRIVING AT 25 MPH AND UNCERTAIN IF WHETHER HE DEPRESSED THE ACCELERATOR PEDAL OR THE BRAKE PEDAL; THE VEHICLE ACCELERATED OFF THE ROAD AND HIT A TREE. THE AIR BAGS DEPLOYED UPON IMPACT. THE CONTACT SUSTAINED MINOR BRUISING AT A RESULT OF THE ACCIDENT BUT DID NOT SEEK MEDICAL TREATMENT. A POLICE REPORT WAS NOT FILED. THE VEHICLE WAS TOTALED AND…