AutoDefects
English

Tesla Model Y vs Tesla Model S

Side by side, from the same official data and the same method.

MeasureTesla Model YTesla Model S
Reliability score37 of 100 · Below average76 of 100 · Average
Mechanical failure rate1.4%7.7%
Class median, same age and mileage0.8%9.1%
Failed MOT (any reason)9.3%20.1%
MOT tests1,73910,760
Best years—2015, 2017, 2018
Years with most failures2022, 2023—
Recalls4843
US owner complaints4,4063,403
Mechanical fail 0-50k km0.6%2.3%
Mechanical fail 50-100k km1.4%3.4%
Mechanical fail 100-150k km3.4%7.5%
Mechanical fail 150k+ km7.7%14.5%

Tesla Model Y

This modelClass median
0%1%2%2022: 2.5%2022 Class median: 1.3%222023: 0.7%2023 Class median: 0.4%23

Tesla Model S

This modelClass median
0%7%15%2014: 16.7%2014 Class median: 20.3%142015: 11.9%2015 Class median: 16.9%152016: 10.1%2016 Class median: 10.3%162017: 6.6%2017 Class median: 8.2%172018: 4.7%2018 Class median: 5.8%182019: 4.7%2019 Class median: 4.4%192020: 3.3%2020 Class median: 3.0%20